Jane Street to challenge India ban, says it engaged in basic arbitrage

Jane Street to challenge India ban, says it engaged in basic arbitrage


Jane Street has told staff it will contest a ban by India’s financial regulator which has accused the U.S. high-frequency trading giant of market manipulation.

Nurphoto | Nurphoto | Getty Images

Jane Street has told staff it will contest a ban by India’s financial regulator which has accused the U.S. high-frequency trading giant of market manipulation, adding that its practices in question were “basic index arbitrage trading”.

Jane Street said it was “beyond disappointed” by what it called “extremely inflammatory” accusations from the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) and is working on a formal response, according to an internal email sent to employees over the weekend that was seen by Reuters.

The email did not elaborate on the potential action that Jane Street might take.

SEBI on Friday barred the firm from buying and selling securities in the Indian market and seized $567 million of its funds.

It alleged that Jane Street bought large quantities of constituents in India’s Bank Nifty index in the cash and futures markets to artificially support the index in morning trade, while simultaneously building large short positions in index options which were exercised or allowed to expire later in the day.

The regulator, which tracked Jane Street’s trading patterns for more than two years, has also widened its investigation to include other indexes and exchanges, a source has said.

Over the past three years, India’s derivatives market has had explosive growth as retail investors swarmed in and is now the world’s largest. But that has also led to losses for many ordinary investors, which has become a concern for regulators.

Seeking lawyers

Jane Street has been sounding out Indian law firms for its upcoming battle with SEBI but has yet to hire one, said four sources with knowledge of the matter. They were not authorised to comment on the matter and declined to be identified.

The next step by Jane Street would likely be to lodge an appeal with the Securities Appellate Tribunal, the sources added.

Jane Street did not immediately reply to a request for comment on Monday.

In its email to staff, Jane Street said arbitrage trades were “a core and commonplace mechanism of financial markets that keeps the prices of related instruments in line.”

SEBI’s order that this activity is “prima facie manipulative” disregards the role of liquidity providers and arbitrageurs in markets, Jane Street added.

The proprietary trading firm also took issue with SEBI’s claims that it had failed to respond adequately to the regulator’s concerns, saying the firm’s executives had met with regulators and exchange officials multiple times.

“Once again, we left this process feeling that we had reached an understanding of the concerns and reflected them in modifications to our trading behaviour.”

“Since February, we have made ongoing efforts to communicate with SEBI and have been consistently rebuffed,” the email said.

SEBI said it had no comment beyond Friday’s order.

India accounted for roughly 60% of global equity derivative trading volume in May, according to the Futures Industry Association.

Data out on Monday showed that equity derivative losses for India’s retail traders widened by 41% to 1.06 trillion Indian rupees ($12.4 billion) in the financial year that ended in March.

SEBI Chairman Tuhin Kanta Pandey also said on Monday that the regulator was enhancing its surveillance to scrutinize manipulation in derivatives trading, but added that there may not be many more cases like Jane Street.

Other overseas proprietary trading firms that are active in India include Citadel Securities, IMC Trading, Millennium and Optiver.



Source

Global stock markets are calling Trump’s bluff on tariffs
World

Global stock markets are calling Trump’s bluff on tariffs

WASHINGTON, DC – JULY 7: An aide picks up a page from a letter to Japan and South Korea, signed by U.S. President Donald Trump, announcing 25% tariffs beginning on August 1st, during the daily press briefing in the Brady Press Briefing Room at the White House on July 7, 2025 in Washington, DC. Andrew […]

Read More
VC behind ‘996’ work culture debate says 5-day weeks won’t build billion-dollar startups
World

VC behind ‘996’ work culture debate says 5-day weeks won’t build billion-dollar startups

Harry Stebbings, founder of 20VC, says billion-dollar firms aren’t built on five-day work weeks. 20VC Venture capitalist Harry Stebbings faced a wave of backlash in June after urging European startup founders to increase their work hours — but he now admits there’s some room for nuance when applying his mantra. Stebbings, founder of 20VC, a […]

Read More
Shein files for Hong Kong IPO in hopes of salvaging London listing: FT report
World

Shein files for Hong Kong IPO in hopes of salvaging London listing: FT report

A shopper carries bags with promotional merchandise while visiting fashion retailer Shein’s Christmas bus tour, in Manchester, Britain, December 13, 2024.  Temilade Adelaja | Reuters Online fast fashion giant Shein has confidentially filed for an initial public offering in Hong Kong in a bid to apply pressure on U.K. regulators and accelerate its long embattled […]

Read More