It’s been 30 years. Here’s why America still can’t agree on charter schools

It’s been 30 years. Here’s why America still can’t agree on charter schools


Whether it’s student loan forgiveness or banning books, education policy in the United States can get contentious.

One controversial education policy that goes back to the 1990s is the charter school.

A charter school is a publicly funded school that is established by a private group. The group creates a contract with the state and local government, which lays out specific accountability requirements. The government has the ability to shut the school down if it doesn’t meet those standards. What’s more, these schools are exempt from certain state laws and regulations that traditional public schools must follow, but they are expected to meet educational standards.

“We have more autonomy to be able to have a more flexible budget and make just different academic decisions,” said Natalie Wiltshire, chief operating officer at KIPP Philadelphia Public Schools.

KIPP, which stands for the “Knowledge Is Power Program,” is the largest charter management organization in the U.S., according to the National Alliance for Public Charter Schools.

Nearly 3,000 students attend KIPP schools in Philadelphia. Admission is determined through a lottery system, with 97% of the students identifying as Black or African American and 76% qualifying for free or reduced lunch.

“KIPP has changed my life immensely,” said Daniel Harris, a KIPP alumnus who is now a teacher at KIPP West Philadelphia Elementary Academy. “My family was lower income, but I know that’s not what [my teachers] saw me as. They saw me as a person who cared about his education, cared about his future, and wanted the best for himself and the people around him. That’s what KIPP was about.”

At the organizational level, though, critics say charter schools harm the wider public school district, due to funding and transparency concerns.

“I’m opposed to publicly funded charter schools that are run privately,” said Joseph Roy, superintendent of schools at the school district in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. “Don’t tell me you’re a public school if you’re not governed by the public.”

When a child leaves a district-run public school, the tax dollars follow that student to the charter school. Opponents of charter schools say even though the student is leaving the school, it doesn’t reduce the traditional public school’s costs.

“What winds up happening is there is a downward spiral because as the money goes out with kids, the services the district can provide become less and less,” said Carol Burris, executive director of the Network for Public Education, an advocacy group that is outspoken against charter schools. “So more parents leave for charter schools. And it puts some districts in critical places where they’re really not able to service the kids that they have.”

“Right now we’re operating parallel school systems and at some point it’s going to break,” Burris said.

Watch the video above to learn why charter schools are still so controversial.



Source

‘Superman’ snares .5 million in Thursday previews on way to 0 million opening
Business

‘Superman’ snares $22.5 million in Thursday previews on way to $140 million opening

David Corenswet stars are Superman in Warner Bros.’ “Superman.” Warner Bros. Discovery It’s not a bird or a plane that soared into cinemas Thursday night — it was Warner Bros.’ “Superman.” The first film in the new era of DC films under James Gunn and Peter Safran snared $22.5 million from preview showings. It’s the […]

Read More
Levi Strauss raises sales guidance, says it will absorb some tariff costs for now
Business

Levi Strauss raises sales guidance, says it will absorb some tariff costs for now

Levi Strauss raised its full-year guidance Thursday and said it’s working to absorb some of the costs it’s facing from higher tariffs, but that could change as President Donald Trump’s trade policy evolves.  The denim maker doesn’t disclose its key manufacturing hubs, but much of its supply comes from Southeast Asia. Many countries in the […]

Read More
IMAX is headed for its best year on record as it capitalizes on Hollywood’s box office rebound
Business

IMAX is headed for its best year on record as it capitalizes on Hollywood’s box office rebound

General atmosphere during an IMAX private screening for the movie “First Man” at an AMC theater in New York City on Oct. 10, 2018. Lars Niki | Getty Images Entertainment | Getty Images More than a year before “F1: The Movie” would eventually hit theaters, Apple struck a deal with IMAX. The studio secured the […]

Read More